Introducing Ice Cream Cakes to Casey Creamery! 


Ice Cream Cakes MUST be ordered in a WEEK OR MORE in advance to when you are wanting your cake (each cake is made to order). Ice Cream Cakes are PICKUP ONLY. Please order online (here) or in person. No email, calling or messaging to place an order. 


Single Cakes: serves approximately 12 people 

Double Cakes: serves approximately 18+ people 

Note: if serving with cake or other treats, you can serve more people with than the reccomended serving amount. 


Select one of our unique flavors for your enjoyment (info section has details for each flavor). Please note that you can make any ice cream cake a "double", which would add more ice cream to serve more people, meaning the price will increase as well. 


Most cakes can be made dairy-free or gluten free by request, but please reach out to us individually if this interests you! Please note that pricing will not be the same for dairy-free or gluten free. 


Please be aware that many of our products do contain common allergens or have been made in a kitchen with commen allergens. Please note in the special requests section if we need to be extra cautious when making your Ice Cream Cake!


Ice Cream Cake Care:

Store in deep freeze until ready to serve with plastic sealed. Reccomended to sit out 10-15 minutes before ready to cut. Use a hot, wet knife to cut ice cream cake. To store, re-tape the box or place into an air tight container to ensure freshness. Ice Cream Cake last up to 6 months if cared for properly. 

Ice Cream Cakes

Ice Cream Cake Flavors
  • Vanilla ice cream blended with Oreo cookies, cookie n fudgy center, and another layer of vanilla ice cream belnded with Oreo cookies. Topped with chocolate and Oreo crumbles.